Mutual of Omaha is one of those companies that doesn’t get a lot of flashy press, but when we talk to people who actually have their Medigap policies, the feedback is consistently positive. “They pick up the phone and they’re helpful” is something we’ve heard more times than we can count — and in the insurance world, that’s not nothing.
We reviewed Mutual of Omaha’s Medigap plans alongside Humana, Cigna, Aetna, and UnitedHealthcare. What stood out most is their AM Best A+ rating (the highest you can get) and their 12% household discount for couples. If you and your spouse are both enrolling in Medigap, that 12% discount is one of the most generous in the market and can save you real money over the years.
David Chen’s parents considered Mutual of Omaha when they were shopping for Medigap. They ended up going with a different carrier that was slightly cheaper in their zip code, but David told us he’d recommend Mutual of Omaha to anyone who values being able to call and talk to a person who actually knows what they’re talking about. Their high-deductible Plan G option is also worth a look if you’re healthy and want to keep premiums low.
Medigap premiums vary by location, age, and other factors, and CMS updates Medicare costs annually. Always verify current rates at medicare.gov or with a free SHIP counselor. Questions? Reach out to us at [email protected] — we read every email.
Mutual of Omaha Medicare Supplement Plan Review 2026
Mutual of Omaha is one of the most respected names in Medigap insurance, consistently earning high marks for financial strength, customer service, and competitive pricing. For seniors who want a reliable partner in their Medicare coverage, Mutual of Omaha deserves serious consideration.
Key Findings
Our research found:
- AM Best A+ rating — the highest financial strength designation
- 12% household discount for couples — among the most generous available
- High-deductible Plan G option — ideal for cost-focused healthy seniors
- Consistently strong customer service — a genuine differentiator
- Broad plan availability across most states
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- AM Best A+ financial rating (top tier)
- 12% household discount — one of the best in the market
- Strong, well-regarded customer service
- High-deductible Plan G available (lower premiums for healthy seniors)
- Plans A, B, D, G, K, L, and N available
Cons:
- Premiums can be slightly higher than lowest-cost competitors in some markets
- Not the cheapest option in every state
- No Plan F for new enrollees (only eligible for those Medicare-eligible before 2020)
Overview of Mutual of Omaha’s Medigap Plans
Basic Coverage — Plans A and B
Plans A and B provide foundational protection. Plan A covers the most essential gaps; Plan B adds the Part A deductible.
Comprehensive Coverage at a Reasonable Price — Plan G
Mutual of Omaha’s Plan G is among the most popular Medigap policies they offer. It covers all Medicare-approved cost-sharing except the annual Part B deductible. After that deductible is met, your out-of-pocket exposure for covered services is essentially zero for the remainder of the year.
High-Deductible Plan G — Lower Premiums for Healthy Seniors
Mutual of Omaha’s high-deductible Plan G option features much lower monthly premiums in exchange for a higher initial deductible (approximately $2,870). Once you’ve met that threshold, full Plan G coverage applies.
Who it’s ideal for: Healthy seniors who want significant financial protection against serious illness or injury but prefer to manage smaller costs themselves.
Cost-Sharing Plans — Plans K and L
Plans K and L offer lower premiums with 50% (Plan K) and 25% (Plan L) cost-sharing respectively, until reaching the annual out-of-pocket maximum.
Balanced Coverage — Plan N
Plan N provides strong coverage at premiums below Plan G. Copays of up to $20 for doctor visits and $50 for non-admission ER visits apply. Does not cover Part B excess charges or the Part B deductible.
International Coverage — Plans D and G
Both Plans D and G include 80% coverage for emergency care outside the US — a meaningful benefit for seniors who travel internationally.
Understanding Mutual of Omaha Medigap Plan Costs
Premiums vary by age, gender, state, and tobacco use. Mutual of Omaha uses attained-age pricing in most markets, meaning premiums increase gradually as you age.
For context, a 70-year-old woman in Michigan might pay approximately $145–$175/month for Plan G through Mutual of Omaha, though prices vary significantly by location.
The 12% household discount applies when a spouse or domestic partner enrolls simultaneously — for couples, this is a meaningful annual savings.
How Mutual of Omaha Compares to Competitors
Mutual of Omaha vs. UnitedHealthcare
Both are top-tier Medigap providers with strong financial ratings. UnitedHealthcare’s AARP endorsement and massive provider network are differentiators. Mutual of Omaha’s 12% household discount and superior AM Best rating (A+ vs. A+) make them a strong alternative. Compare specific prices in your zip code.
Mutual of Omaha vs. Humana
Humana covers all 50 states with more plan letters available. Mutual of Omaha’s household discount (12%) is significantly higher than Humana’s. For individual seniors, compare premiums directly; for couples, Mutual of Omaha’s discount usually wins on total cost.
Mutual of Omaha vs. Aetna
Aetna is frequently the lowest-priced carrier in many markets. Mutual of Omaha competes on customer service quality and financial strength. Both are strong choices — price-sensitive seniors should compare both quotes.
Additional Benefits
Beyond standardized coverage, Mutual of Omaha offers:
- Online account management for policy and billing management
- Pharmacy discount program — access to prescription discounts at participating pharmacies
- Responsive claims processing — known for timely and accurate claims handling
How to Enroll in Mutual of Omaha Medigap
- Confirm you’re enrolled in Medicare Parts A and B
- Get a quote at mutualofomaha.com or by calling their Medicare supplement line
- Apply during your Open Enrollment Period (within 6 months of Part B effective date)
- Provide your Medicare ID, Part B effective date, and personal information
For couples, apply together to receive the 12% household discount.
Our Verdict
Mutual of Omaha earns a top recommendation for Medigap, particularly for:
- Couples seeking the best household discount (12%)
- Service-focused seniors who prioritize responsive, high-quality customer support
- Health-conscious seniors seeking the high-deductible Plan G option for lower premiums
Compare their premiums against Aetna and Humana in your specific area before making a final decision.